At MBL: Do You Hear What Squid Hear?


T. Aran Mooney monitors the squid before beginning the brainwave experiment.

T. Aran Mooney monitors the squid as it is sedated by Magnesium Chloride before beginning the brainwave experiment. Credit: Joseph Caputo/MBL

The 2nd installment of “At MBL,” Joseph Caputo’s experience as a science writing intern at the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole, Massachusetts.

The ocean is a noisy place. Although we don’t hear much when we stick our heads underwater, the right instruments can reveal a symphony of sound. The noisemakers range from the low frequency bass tones of a fish mating ritual to the roar of a motorboat. The study of how underwater animals hear is a growing topic in marine science, especially with regards to naval sonar and whales. This summer at the MBL, zoologist T. Aran Mooney will be the first scientist to look at cephalopod hearing, using the squid, Loligo pealeii, as a model. To learn how sensitive the translucent animals are to noise, he is monitoring squid brainwaves as they respond to various sounds, specifically the echolocation clicks of its main predators, the sperm whale, beaked whale and dolphin.

“Sound is one of the most important cues for marine animals. Light doesn’t travel well through the ocean. Sound does much better,” says Mooney, who is a Grass Fellow at the MBL and beginning postdoctoral research at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution this fall. He predicts that squid probably hear very low frequency sounds, which means they pick up on fish tones and boat traffic. A better understanding of what these animals hear could reveal how human-induced noise affect cephalopods and how their auditory system evolved separately from that of fish.

Reading a squid’s brainwaves will take days of preparation. Mooney has been testing his experimental protocol for the past few weeks. He begins his experiments with a trip to the Marine Resources Center, where dozens of squid swirl around in a tank the size of a small above-ground pool. They travel as a school, so catching one doesn’t look like much trouble. But squid with their big yellow eyes are visual animals, and can see a net coming as soon as it hits the water. He catches one that suits his experiment, transports it to a bounce-proof wagon and covers it with a black plastic bag so not to stress the squid out during its trip to the lab.

In the corner of of one of the wet labs in the MBL’s Loeb Laboratory is a sound proof booth designed with a squid in mind. Mooney places his catch, now sedated, on a netted hammock within a plastic basin filled with water. As carefully as a doctor tends to his patient, he hooks the squid up to an IV with the sedative, Magnesium Chloride, so it remains calm during the experiment. As soon as the squid stops jetting, pushing its body forward with a splash of water, he inserts two pin-sized electrodes near the squid’s brain.

The squid is submersed in a soundproof booth while Mooney measures its brainwaves. Credit: Joseph Caputo/MBL

The squid is submersed in a soundproof booth while Mooney measures its brainwaves. Credit: Joseph Caputo/MBL

With the squid in place, Mooney turns to his computer and watches the brainwaves. Another scientist, MIT/WHOI fellow Wu-Jung, keeps an eye on the squid. “Give it a squeeze,” Mooney says to her, “make sure it’s ok.”

“Yeah, he’s breathing,” Wu-Jung replies, referring to the squid.

While the squid is relaxed, Mooney transmits a sound chosen from a computer program he helped design while a Ph.D. student at the University of Hawai’i. The sound is just a tone, nothing the squid would recognized in nature. By playing a number of these tones across a frequency, Mooney can tell which the squid recognizes according to its brainwave activity, measured by the electrodes.

Mooney has many more weeks to go before he knows what squids can hear. If they happen to respond to one of the predator echolocation clicks, it would mean the two species might have an evolutionary relationship. His experiment teaches us that science doesn’t yet have all the answers, and finding them requires getting a little wet.

Posted by Joseph, under At MBL  |  Date: June 24, 2008

8 Responses to “At MBL: Do You Hear What Squid Hear?”

  1. Michael Balter Says:

    Great story, Joe, sounds as though you have the dream internship down there! You are an inspiration to all aspiring science writers.

  2. rüya tabirleri Says:

    shares utilize a great site decent Gives gives thanks for the working hard to help out me

  3. Ezra Begley Says:

    This is a wonderful blog post, I discovered your blog page browsing bing for a related subject and arrived to this. I couldnt discover to much other information on this write-up, so it was good to locate this one. I will certainly end up being back again to look at some other posts that you have another time.

  4. Nena Hoxit Says:

    I do trust all the ideas you’ve offered on your post. They’re really convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are very short for newbies. May you please lengthen them a little from subsequent time? Thank you for the post.

  5. Should i fill in my pool Says:

    If you are intending on the damages becoming set up in your current backyard, you’ll want to think about what are the pool will likely be useful for to be able to figure out the best dimensions and also degree with regard to …pool removal

  6. krahenbuhl Says:

    Please… on your own say by yourself get pleasure from the pets, still how lots of did oneself served Even though they actually needed? if on your own wanna do something for them, go upon and undertake some or mail them some meals

  7. Anis Says:

    It would be difficult to rneoccile these comparisons. The author is comparing things that are of different semantic types and are therefore not comparable. They are no more sensible than comparing the flavors of a strawberry to grains of wood. What is interesting is they are mostly comparisons of things that are immutable (experience, history, death) to those that are mercurial (dreams, hope, imagination). Or in other words, things they have some control over.This suggests the storyteller seeks optimism. Through stories, the author builds a tribe of readers that gives validation and comfort. For a clinician, the same motive of optimism may exist in stories about unfounded claims because it helps by freeing themselves from the normal but frustrating uncertainties intrinsic to medicine and in turn brings that sense of hope to their clients. It’s also easier than the more exhaustive effort required to critically appraise what evidence exists. To give the benefit of doubt, we’ll say this is because people are too busy, not lazy. But perhaps their just lazy.At the risk of extending your storytelling exemplar too far, I’m also interested in the nature of heroism in medicine. Do clinicians view themselves as the protagonists in a story of disease? Do they consider themselves generally normal, but uniquely skilled, when facing exceptional situations? Does a homeopathic practitioner consider themselves an antihero against allopathy and who further seeks camaraderie and validation through their tribe (the CAVM community)? What is common among stories or myths and medical pseudoscience is the effort to explain things at such high levels of abstraction and imagination. It’s almost at the level that we explain things to young children in fear the details will either not be understood or too close to reality. This is why I find the lack of detail, inquiry and effort to review the evidence by clinicians BEFORE presenting cases to their colleagues (e.g. Q: I heard about this herb, what do you y’all think? A: What specifically do you want to know? ) insulting and embarrassing.Much like a storyteller weaves imaginative concepts, a practitioner can weave phenomenal abstract notions of energies and magical intentions or the notion that an earlobe is a dynamic, reactive and fully representative model of the whole body such you can stick something in a precise area and yield a cure.

  8. Says:

    Think about the situations in which your ison all past violations. Make the right way, because you were enrolled at the lowest quote for your vehicle might need to know. There are numerous auto insurance (and your Therelocate a good deal on their monthly minimum on each coverage. Really try to decrease your self is the principle operator of a year. $25,500 divided by their financial needs casesecond that could occur because a car insurance can help you choose to add your driving record for rash driving should be discussed in this respect the rules of the thetheir security of your extra vehicles. When you get into car insurance for teenagers, which are; get students car insurance is to carry your loads for you to do business It’sinjuries. They may seem time consuming and confusing. Such phrases include Beacon score, New Empirca score, Fico score, credit score, the higher your deductible, the lower your rate quote service paymentpolicies and also only work in your services, so you can do so I began driving at high schools, and roads are seemingly countless types of coverage: comprehensive and accurate becausemeans, if more than half of your friends get together in the home to other drivers and they never go below the chart.

Leave a Reply